Reviews For Bloom of a Rose

Name: Idril Anarion (Anonymous) · Date: May 01, 2012 10:31 am · For: Chapter 8: Strangers in the Night.

You have GOT to update soon!!! Give I'd like to see more of Elladan and Legolas' friendship, and more of Elrohir's jealousy
Please, oh, please continue :3

Name: petey (Anonymous) · Date: April 27, 2011 07:08 pm · For: Chapter 8: Strangers in the Night.

Wonderful. Please continue.

Name: massanie (Anonymous) · Date: June 27, 2009 08:47 am · For: Chapter 8: Strangers in the Night.

How very, very mean of you to stop at such a moment and not updating for FIFE months ;-)

I liked to read it very much and hope you´ll soon continue ...

Name: Puck (Anonymous) · Date: June 14, 2009 09:51 am · For: Chapter One: A star rises out of darkness...

Hey Andrea,

I loved to read it. It was great. I simply love the Imladris elves. And the famous Balrog slayer is my absolute favorite.

Im studying as well and have to admit, that you kept me from learning ;-). So I understand you totally. Nevertheless I hope to read more soon ...

Only critic: There are some parts of the story you kept out (In the last chapter, when Elrond sends for Glorfindel for example) that I would be interested in reading. And why do the twins have to be so ... dislikable? As the sons of Elrond and friends of Aragorn and the rangers surely they would be solemn but friendly and maybe plain? At least they were in my imagination ;-)

Keep on writing

Robin Goodfellow alias Puck


You must login (register) to review.