Reviews For Mael-Gûl

Name: Candi (Anonymous) · Date: September 09, 2016 02:53 pm · For: Chapter 7. Crossing the Mountains IV

Excellent! I've been enthralled. I'm sorry the story hasn't been continued.


Name: Isthimiel (Anonymous) · Date: August 02, 2015 02:35 am · For: Chapter 7. Crossing the Mountains IV

Thank you! I very much appreciate your story and hope that you can continue it soon.

Name: StepByStep (Signed) · Date: February 11, 2015 11:09 pm · For: Chapter 7. Crossing the Mountains IV

I've really enjoyed reading the story thus far! Particularly with the complex and pitifully tragic relationship between Aragorn and Legolas. It's hard watching Aragorn do everything he does to Legolas, but harder to hate him for it, especially knowing what bitter irony it resulted from.

Above all, I believe I enjoyed the relationship between Legolas and Boromir. The slow gaining of trust and respect was really heartwarming and notable. I love seeing Boromir's kindness and interactions because, before the corruption of the ring, we know that he was a very noble and honorable man, yet we see sadly little of it. I can only dread future chapters when the Boromir that's grown on us must die. How tragic that end will be! 

Still, if you follow the plot, we should be seeing a similar type of growth between Gimli and Legolas. One that even Boromir's shouldn't be able to compare to. I really look forward to seeing that, if you ever plan on continuing this.

Overall, I'll say that I very much loved this story, and would really appreciate it if you would choose to continue.

Name: Lumiel Alatar (Anonymous) · Date: March 05, 2014 05:02 pm · For: Chapter 1. Return to Rivendell

Oh, they talk about the poor elf as if they were talking about a mere toy.
Well, this is the first legolas-slave-fic that I read in wich he doesn't hate Aragorn with his entire being.

Name: Andrea (Anonymous) · Date: December 19, 2013 03:46 am · For: Prologue

I'm Grace writting on a borrowed movile. I found your fic so good to not be finished! Elrond is a yerk, Gimli is dark , Aragorn doesn't deserve Legolas love and loyalty from the moment he started to enjoy his sexual toy' painfull. the tipical warrior, proud rough but tender and in this last chapter, he made fall at his feet! The way he ask for Legolas forgiveness, how he recognize his behavior and the opened door to a tender relatioship between them, I love this man! He can love Legolas without pain, the elf deserves that! Gave them a chance and don't Boromir die please! Finish the story !!!!!

Name: Andrea (Anonymous) · Date: December 10, 2013 02:48 pm · For: Chapter 7. Crossing the Mountains IV

Very good! But I hope you finish it because I felt a bit dissapointed with the last chapter's ending. I find more appropiate Legolas/Boromir relatioship for their tenderness but you are following the story and in a certain moment Boromir would die and it's not fair! Change this end please and give him a chance! Wait for more...

Name: Melodie_Gael (Anonymous) · Date: July 05, 2013 07:45 am · For: Chapter 3. After the Council

Well, this is really well written! The subject is quite a challenge and at some point i felt a bit not at ease reading it -but you definitely managed to channel all the shadows, all the sides of the characters, pain, relief, love and all. Apart from that Elrdon's a real jerk!:P And i came to this fic having vowed to read all the Leg/Gimli fics of the,we will see more of the dwarf later?*disturbing tought* Many compliments again, i'll keep on reading when i gater the courage!:)

You must login (register) to review.