Site Info
We are the home of 1292 authors from among our 2554 members. There have been 2904 reviews written about our 3820 stories consisting of 10734 chapters and 29400445 words. A special welcome to our newest member, Esra.Categories
Skin Change
Donate
Help us keep one of the oldest running LotR archives available to all. Even the smallest donation helps!
Many thanks to our previous donors!
Many thanks to our previous donors!
The Library, elsewhere
Other projects
Reviews For When the Days Were Long
Name: Tristana (Signed) · Date: July 02, 2012 04:42 pm · For: Chapter 1
Where to start? There are several reasons why I adore your story. One would be the epic slash. Though it makes sense, I have to say that this is the first story I come across in which the full potential of these three is exploited. And you made me the happiest fangirl this side of Middle-Earth (so to say).
Yes, Maedhros is clueless, but he's all the more loveable for this. Though I have to say that it's sometimes annoying. But anyway. I like your idea - having Fingon leading Maedhros to see. And this is plain sweet and I need no other reason than this.
Though the smut was... *fans self* Okay, now, I'll be out in the rain, I'll be right back.
Also, the end of your story made it... not sad, but still. Nostalgic somehow. (Listening to sad songs at the same time is not a good idea apparently.) I really loved it - and the fact that it was not some PWP.
So to sum it up - I am sorry for the long rant: your story is well-written, nosebleed-inducing, and is definitely a favourite of mine from now.
Thank you for writing this story, and for sharing it. *offers cookies in thanks*
(Now I want to hug them even more than I usually do...
Fingon: And I thought Balrogs were the last thing you'd want to see. I take that back.) /goes off before being too creepy.
Where to start? There are several reasons why I adore your story. One would be the epic slash. Though it makes sense, I have to say that this is the first story I come across in which the full potential of these three is exploited. And you made me the happiest fangirl this side of Middle-Earth (so to say).
Yes, Maedhros is clueless, but he's all the more loveable for this. Though I have to say that it's sometimes annoying. But anyway. I like your idea - having Fingon leading Maedhros to see. And this is plain sweet and I need no other reason than this.
Though the smut was... *fans self* Okay, now, I'll be out in the rain, I'll be right back.
Also, the end of your story made it... not sad, but still. Nostalgic somehow. (Listening to sad songs at the same time is not a good idea apparently.) I really loved it - and the fact that it was not some PWP.
So to sum it up - I am sorry for the long rant: your story is well-written, nosebleed-inducing, and is definitely a favourite of mine from now.
Thank you for writing this story, and for sharing it. *offers cookies in thanks*
(Now I want to hug them even more than I usually do...
Fingon: And I thought Balrogs were the last thing you'd want to see. I take that back.) /goes off before being too creepy.
